Showing posts with label Opinions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Opinions. Show all posts

21 December, 2011

On YA Fiction: Political Messages

Recently, I've been noticing a trend in Young Adult, particularly in Science Fiction and its sub-genres Dystopian/Futuristic Fiction. There seem to be more and more books that revolve around a central political idea: over-reaching government.

Take Matched by Allie Condie, Possession by Elana Johnson, The Giver by Lois Lowry, The Knife of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness, Birthmarked by Caragh O'Brien, Delirium by Lauren Oliver, The Maze Runner by James Dashner, Gone by Michael Grant, Little Brother and For the Win by Cory Doctorow, The Tomorrow Code by Brian Falkner, The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, and I could come up with others if I had more time. I'd also mention Divergent by Veronica Roth and Wither by Lauren Destefano, since they seem to be political based on their blurbs, but I haven't read those yet so I can't say for sure.

As you may have noticed, many of those are quite popular (*cough*The Hunger Games*cough*), and in addition, many of them seem to be rather anti-government. The Giver by Lois Lowry seems to be the exception, though it could still be taken as anti-government, since POTENTIAL SPOILER ALERT one of the central characters is influential in preventing pain within the city--this, of course, also leads to more control, but everyone besides a certain few are oblivious to suffering.


Another element that repeats itself is revolutionaries/the resistance. In almost all of the above books, the main character joins or helps an organization (whether paramilitary or not) that, in turn, has some kind of showdown with the omnipresent government.

Now, while I don't mind politics in books, the constant battering of "Government Is Evil!" is beginning to make me wonder why it's cropping up so often.

Is it the political climate today, with a bad economy, constant protests, the Arab Spring, the war in Afghanistan and very recently Iraq? Is it a response to the perceived "rise of China" and Communism, the nuclear capabilities of other countries that might not have the Western world's best interests in mind?

Or is that reading too much of it, and it's just an attempt to appeal to teenagers that feel oppressed by their peers, their parents, society in general? But then again, it's not just teenagers reading YA; it attracts a wide range of readers.


What do you think?

And do you mind politics in the books you read? Is it something you're attracted or repelled by, in general?


-----The Golden Eagle

16 June, 2011

How Much Do Online Reviews Mean To You?

Nowadays, practically everything is reviewed. Books. Movies. Food. Services. You name it. Along with that, of course, are the sites that put those reviews up on the Internet. Reviews come in all different kinds--basic, word-free star ratings, long paragraphs, essay-long rambles, rants, and so forth.

Some are by popular, well-known companies or people who have either done something in relation to what they're reviewing; and some of them are by random people who decided to share their opinions.

On the whole, how much do you think those opinions are worth?

For example, I was looking up a movie I saw last week* on (the? Do you put a "the" before the acronym?) IMDb (Internet Movie Database). I wanted to know what other people thought of it, since my mom and I ended up discussing it for a while afterwards.


Most of the reviews were glowing, such as "A milestone of revelation" and "PERFECTION! ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT." and "A masterpiece filmed, edited and directed by geniuses". A few other reviews, on the other hand, said such things as "manipulative, racist, simple-minded, self-congratulating" and "a glorified roll of stock footage" and "Pretentious drivel." (Links to reviews.)

And there was one that actually made me laugh a bit:

"When, atop snow-dusted mountain, you countenance the day's burning embers unfurling like crimson ribbons beneath a churning sky-scape of blushing clouds, doesn't it just make you want to... buy a car with optional four-wheel steering and an eight-speed automatic transmission?" (Credit.)

(Ha!)

As you can see, the style and attitude of these reviews varies greatly. That's the whole point of reviewing things, no? So people can find out if what other people said strikes any chords with them. But how much time, energy, and effort are you supposed to spend reading through dozens, hundreds, even thousands of reviews for a single thing?

Another factor is: I don't know the reviewers. They're random people, and while some of the reviews are very well-written and helpful, I don't know anything about the reviewer. At least when I read something by a blogger, I know (in a broad sense, anyway) what they like, and in relation to the thing being reviewed.


I don't mean to sound hypocritical in my skepticism on how much reviews are worth--yes, I write book and movie reviews (and I'd be willing to write reviews for other stuff, but hey, it's not like people are flocking to my doorstep). However, I rarely review things off of my blog, and as I mentioned above, I consider blogs to be a different matter. There's more than a profile behind a blogger, especially if you've been reading their posts for a while.

I can also understand wanting other people to review what you've done. I know I'd want people reviewing my book on a site, because that means it's getting attention.

It's just the volume of the reviews in the world, especially for relatively popular products. There are a gazillion of them. Most of the time, I just glance at the star-rating, the blurb or advertising attached to the object in question, and skim a few of the reviews at the top of the page.


How much stock to you put in online reviews, on any subject? Do you read online reviews, and if so, which ones and by who?


How many reviews of something do you have read, before you decide whether to check it out or not? What kind of reviews do you most often look at--written reviews, video reviews, star reviews? Do you write reviews?

(*The movie, in case you're wondering, is Baraka.)


-----The Golden Eagle

26 May, 2011

Do You Have To Like The Main Character To Enjoy A Book?

I've come across novels where I really didn't like the main character, or just felt indifferent toward her/him--but whose plot and setting I enjoyed.

(SOURCE. Do ignore the URL. It's safe. :P)

For example, The Cup of the World by John Dickinson. The main character, Phaedra of Trant, did some things that were naive (and a bit stupid), which just seemed to attest again and again that she was a very strange person. But I read the other two books in the trilogy and liked them as well, for the world the story was set it was amazing (full of its twists and turns and personality, if a world can have personality) and the plot was so complex. The other two books also had characters I didn't like--however, I still felt like that The Widow and the King and The Fatal Child, were definitely worth the read for the other aspects to them.

I felt the same way about books such as The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, the first book in The Genius Wars series by Catherine Jinks, and others. I just didn't like the characters, but I did like the plot and setting of the books. A lot, enough to give them at least a 4-star rating (for those of you who haven't read my book reviews, I go to within a tenth of a decimal point) even if they weren't particular favorites.


Which brings up the question:

How much do you have to like the main character(s) to enjoy a book? How much can you stand from a character before it really affects your opinion of a story? Can you think of any examples where you would have liked a book more if the main character(s) had been more appealing to you?


-----The Golden Eagle

03 March, 2011

My Crusader Group, Poll Results, And Award

I noticed other people were posting their Crusader Groups, as a way of welcoming the others who write in the same genre/age group/etc., so I decided to do the same. :)


Here's a list of everyone in the Fantasy/Science Fiction Group, which is where I am:


1. Dominic de Mattos (Writes of Passage) [Twitter] Fantasy, science fiction 

2. Anica Grey (Butterfly Mind) [Twitter] Science-fiction, fantasy 

3. Sandra Ulbrich Almazan (Sandra Ulbrich Almazan: Speculative Fiction Author) Science fiction, fantasy 

4. Tony Benson (Fireside Park) Science fiction, fantasy (with a paranormal element) 

5. The Golden Eagle (The Eagle's Aerial Perspective) Science fiction, fantasy, adventure/action, YA 



Me. ;)

6. Mlle Lizka (Laws of Gravity) Fantasy (with science fiction elements) 

7. Chris Kelworth (The Kelworth Files) Science fiction, fantasy 

8. Mercy (Have Mercy! Killer Reviews) [Twitter] Fantasy, science fiction 

9. Rogue Mutt (Every Other Writer Has a Blog...Why Can't I?) Science fiction, fantasy 

10. Charity Bradford (My Writing Journey) [Twitter] Science fiction, fantasy (with a heavy dose of adventure and romance) 

11. Gen Jordan (Living on Earth) Science fiction, fantasy, occasional fan-fiction 

12. Pensheep (A Writerly Pensheep) [Twitter] Speculative fiction, literary fiction 

13. K. Howard (Morike of the Chair) Science fiction, fantasy 

14. Cindy Borgne (Dreamer's Perch) [Twitter] Science fiction, fantasy, paranormal, inspirational 

15. Michael Offutt (SLC Kismet) Science fiction, speculative fiction, fantasy, urban fantasy, dark fantasy 


So, welcome to my blog, fellow Crusaders! I believe I follow all of you, or are subscribed to your blog--if I don't follow you, do speak up so I can get to your blog!


*****


You know the poll I had on my sidebar? Well, it got 61 votes (61!), the question being "Which genre do you write in the most?" and the results are:


17 of you write Science Fiction.
26 write Fantasy.
3 write Thriller/Mystery.
7 write Romance.
5 write Realistic Fiction.
1 write Paranormal.
2 write in another genre I didn't include in the options.

Interesting. Fantasy obviously trumped everything else, but I guess that's to be expected. A lot of you do seem to be in that genre! Which is cool. I've written it myself, and still do--if I'm in the mood for magic and dragons and evil powers and everything else that's in Fantasy--although Science Fiction was my answer.

*****

I was awarded by Cally Jackson at the blog of the same name. Thank you, Cally!


And because I've been awarded before with the Stylish Blogger, I'm going to pass on listing seven things about myself and offer this up to anyone who wants to take it. Seriously. If you want this stylish award and wish to pass it on, feel free!

*****

Also, don't forget you still have until Sunday to ask me questions for my blogoversary celebration!


-----The Golden Eagle

12 December, 2010

Book Review: Nomansland


Title: Nomansland
Author: Lesley Hauge
Publisher: Henry Holt and Company LLC
Genre: Dystopian/Speculative Fiction
Page Count: 243
Rating: 4 out of 5
Cover Rating: 4.5 out of 5. I really like this cover--the horse, girl, and bow/arrow all fit the book.

Inside flap:
Sometime in the future, after wars and fires have devastated the earth, a lonely, windswept island is populated solely by women. The women have survived against all odds by working hard in the fields. Their lives are tough.
   Among these women is a group of teenage Trackers--expert equestrians and archers--who are in training to protect their shores from the enemy. The enemy, they've been told, is men.
   When these girls come upon a partially buried home from the distant past, they are fascinated by the strange objects--high-heeled shoes, teen magazines, makeup--found there. What are they to make of these mysterious things, which introduce a world they have never known? And what does it mean for their strict society where friendship is forbidden and the rules must be obeyed--at all costs?

My expectations: I'm all for strong women and independence with regards to the female gender--so I was intrigued by the blurb, although I wasn't sure what to make of the "high-heeled shoes, teen magazines, makeup" part of it.


I found this an interesting book, meeting my expectations.

About the book: This book is a view of feminism taken to the extremes--with no men in the society at all, and the women are isolated and worked hard to support the community. They all have their different areas--the main character, Keller, is a Tracker trained to protect the borders of Foundland.


It wasn't really a book about women being strong/independent--it was dark and occasionally disturbing, and some the thoughts presented surprised me. For example, Ms. Windsor ***Minor spoilers here, nothing really serious*** believes that the Bible is all about subduing and presenting women as evil and seducing men--and that women were abused and treated badly when they tried to please men by dressing up/using makeup/etc.


To keep the society going, "Committee" members force the girls and women into artificial insemination. The "Seed" is described as being a painful and gruesome experience. The male children are taken away; it never explains what happens to them.


As for the the writing, it was strong. I liked the narrative, and I could picture the bleak world they lived in well.


  • Plot:

I could predict some things that happened, but that doesn't mean it was weak. The plot was very good overall, and there were some surprises. The ending was satisfying enough, and lived up to the rest of the novel.


  • Characters:
I didn't know what to make of Keller. Sometimes she seemed like a determined person, and other times she was dragged along with the rest of the crowd, not really thinking for herself--I did not like her generally, but she was an interesting character to read about.

Laing wasn't sensible. She was desperate for attention, and popularity, and I much preferred Keller over her--however, she was an interesting representation of a kind of person from modern society.

Ms. Windsor was a scary person, and complex. She wasn't evil, precisely, just blinded by her opinions. And her opinions were extreme, going to the farthest end of feminism and women that you can go. I didn't like her, either, but she was a terrifying person to read about.


There are no characters that I really enjoyed--they all have their sides, some ugly, some dark, some noble, some twisted. But despite that I couldn't really like any of them, each has their own personality, which I appreciated.


  • Setting/Elements:

There are aspects to it that are thought-provoking (I know, overused phrase, but it's true) and it brought some interesting ideas on society and women.

The world was intriguing--I wanted to know more about it. It seemed like a rough environment, and I wonder where it was corresponding to current locations/countries; there were remnants of a "Time Before" that was clearly like the modern era.

Other: The descriptions of the "Seed" were disturbing; there's also violence, some language, cruelty, and references. It's not a very light read.

Do I recommend this book? Yes, if you want an interesting read on another perspective of women, and what it might be like in an all-female society.

-----The Golden Eagle

19 November, 2010

Ease or Throw the Reader?

Some books put the reader straight into the setting the story is based on. Others try to ease you into it, through discoveries made by the main character.

I prefer the kind of book that puts you straight into the setting without preamble, another reason SF/F are my favorite genres most of the time. There's no preamble, and things are usually described in the first chapter or so, as you get used to the character's surroundings. Or they're just stated, and the reader is shown how the world works.

Easing the reader into the story--sucking them in, even though there are just clues as to something bigger that may or may not be around the corner--can be hard, and it's easy to bungle. A lot of authors pull it off well, but some do not. I find this especially with books where the protagonist is finding out something about another character, who typically has some sort of secret behind his/her existence, or when the secret's about the MC him/herself.

One problem I find with simply putting the reader into the story is because some things just don't make sense at first. I can occasionally get lost in Science Fiction with the technology--the books appeal to my geek side, but sometimes it's hard to understand the jargon, especially when it comes to things like gaming. (I know little about gaming.) And sometimes the terms are completely made up, and you have to guess what they're talking about, which can be annoying.

But easing the reader into the story can be jagged and feel wrong. The discovery has to be smooth and not terribly obvious, so that the reader has something to actually guess at. Otherwise, that part of the magic is lost. It can work if the reader already knows what's behind whatever's happening in the story, but if the character is unrealistically reacting to things and saying something that fit their character (or general common sense) then it doesn't. And when the MC finds out the secret . . . well, they can't be all "ooooh, goody!" or "I still trust you besides the fact you can kill me and I know practically nothing about you!" because in good ol' Real Life people don't do that. They freak out and tell their friends the person's insane.

Hopefully, anyway.

I could be being too literal with this . . . it's just fiction. But if the world isn't presented right, or if there's something I don't understand, it bugs me. I like my books wrapped up tight, and if they're not, then I tend to get frustrated.


What do you think? Ease, or throw the reader into the story? Do you prefer either? Does it affect your opinion of a book if the beginning events aren't explained completely, or if the protagonist is reacting in a way that's not true to life?


-----The Golden Eagle